The In-Laws (2003)
Starring Albert Brooks, Michael Douglas, Ryan Reynolds, Lindsay Sloane, Candice Bergen, Robin Tunney, David Suchet.
Directed by Andrew Bergman.
Rated PG-13.
Grade: B-
"They weren't caterers! They were a man and his wife, and... lettuce!"
This is what the phrase "star power" really means. Neither Michael Douglas
nor Albert Brooks are guaranteed box-office draws, though they probably
bring their own audiences with them. But more important than the commercial
fate that The In-Laws is destined or doomed to experience is this: despite
the fact that the script is pretty shoddy work through and through, the film
itself is absurdly, gloriously entertaining. Why? Because the actors are
permitted to do what they do best: Brooks gets to play Woody Allen better
than Woody Allen himself; Douglas gets to project his trademark unflappable
self-confidence in service of a more amiable character than he usually plays
significant change of pace for an actor who earned his fame and fortune
playing greedy, unfeeling assholes).
This is a remake of a 1979 Arthur Hiller comedy (now there's a career down
the crapper). It doesn't really matter. Nothing matters very much in this
movie, except perhaps the relative screentimes of the actors, and certainly
not the details of the plot. In any case, here they are: Dr. Jerry Peyser
wedding. He is a podiatrist for the sole purpose of the joke where the
Douglas character, unaware of the field of medicine in which Peyser
practices, comments about how stressful it must be to constantly worry about
saving lives, only to have the movie cut to Peyser warning a woman about the
dangers of her foot fungus. Douglas plays Steve Tobias, the father of the
groom, and he is an undercover CIA agent.
Jerry, in his perpetually befuddled, neurotic state of mind, manages to get
himself embroiled in Tobias's plot to intercept a nuclear submarine
affectionately named Olga and thwart some baddies in the process (though it
isn't immediately clear what his intentions are). The foot doctor also earns
the ire of Tobias's tough and impatient partner Angela (Robin Tunney), and
the unreasonable admiration of a flamboyant arms dealer named Jean-Pierre,
to whom he is presented as legendary gangster Fat Cobra (Jean-Pierre: "How
many kills do you have?" Jerry: "Six.").
Other supporting players show up, most notably the underrated Candice Bergen
as Tobias's disgruntled ex-wife. The movie throws together improbable scenes
of espionage and narrow escape with perhaps even more improbable ones of
rehearsal dinners, bachelorette parties and, finally, the actual wedding.
The newlyweds, by the way, are played by the lovely Lindsay Sloane and the
impossibly dull Ryan Reynolds.
Yeah, so, okay: that's what The In-Laws is about. It could have been
unwatchable . I can easily imagine this being the worst movie of the year, a
droning, witless comedy relying on the oh-so-clever conglomeration of two
separate genres to net laughs. But here's the thing: Michael Douglas has not
made an awful movie in his entire career and he doesn't seem about to start
now. He and Brooks team up to pull this movie out of the gutter by sheer
persistence and willpower. Without them, this would have been exactly the
movie I feared it would be.
While Brooks has always specialized in nervous, fidgety characters who
deliver zingy one-liners without seeming to realize it, his resemblance to
Woody Allen here is just uncanny. When, somewhere in the second act, he has
to improvise a monologue about how his skin is actually not waterproof and
will let in water should he be forced to take a bath, I could have sworn I
was watching Manhattan Murder Mystery, part II. Jerry's perpetual
bewilderment is one joke that is milked for the entire ninety-minute running
time, but when Brooks is the one milking it, I don't mind. I've always
thought that Allen's personality and ear for sharp dialogue overrules the
regrettable fact that his movies and characters are always essentially the
same, and I'm beginning to apply that to Brooks as well.
As for Douglas, he's just himself, and that's enough. He is such a beautiful
contrast to Brooks' confused persona that whenever a script requires an "odd
couple", you could not do better than casting these two. With any luck, The
In-Laws is the beginning of a wonderful new friendship.
